Oil may drop to low $30s without extension of OPEC supply cut, says ABN Amro

LONDON (Bloomberg) -- Crude prices could plunge toward $30/bbl -- a rout of about 40% from current levels -- unless OPEC extends production cuts that are propping up the market, ABN Amro Bank NV said.

The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries agreed at the end of November to limit collective production cuts by 1.2 MMbpd. It then got support from non-member nations, most notably Russia, that meant total planned curbs of about 1.8 MMbpd. However, the agreed period for those reductions was the first half of this year, leaving uncertainty about what happens from July.

“If they don’t continue with this trend, then the oil price could drop back to where it was two years ago,” Hans van Cleef, ABN Amro’s senior energy economist, said in an interview with Bloomberg’s Oil Buyer’s Guide, adding he’s unsure whether the deal to restrict supplies will persist. “Oil prices could easily go back to the low $30s.”

After an initial surge when the cuts were announced, crude prices have traded in an ever-narrower range amid signs U.S. producers are filling the supply void created when OPEC and its allies reduced output. Futures in New York are stuck in the tightest range in 13 years and Brent implied volatility is around the lowest in more than two years, data compiled by Bloomberg show. The markets are becalmed even though money managers hold record contracts betting on a rally, equating to more than 1 Bbbl of oil.

Since October, the baseline month for most OPEC cuts, the U.S. added almost 500,000 bpd of production, Energy Information Administration data show. The 11 OPEC nations that participated in the cuts accord lowered their daily output by about 1.14 MMbbl. Libya and Nigeria, OPEC members that weren’t required to take part, added about 220,000 bpd.

Van Cleef said his view is that the “downside risk has become much bigger than previously,” with signs that the market had already priced in the production cuts. With compliance at about 90% -- a historically high level -- “we don’t see any upside from OPEC anymore,” he said. “What we do see is more risk of higher production in the U.S., we see a rise in inventories.”